Justia New Hampshire Supreme Court Opinion Summaries

Articles Posted in Constitutional Law
by
Police in Seabrook, New Hampshire, were investigating reports of drug sales at a particular apartment complex. They received multiple tips, including one specifically naming a red Chevrolet Cruze and a silver Honda Civic, with license plate numbers, as being involved in these activities. The Cruze was registered to a woman living in the investigated complex, and she had previously been identified in reports as a suspected drug dealer. On June 2, 2023, an officer observed the Cruze with two occupants—a woman presumed to be the registered owner and a male passenger. The officer followed the vehicle from Seabrook to an apartment complex in Methuen, Massachusetts, known to be connected to drug activity. After about ten minutes at that location, the Cruze left, made a brief stop at a store parking lot, and then returned to Seabrook. The officer observed no traffic violations but did note "excessive blinker usage" and requested another officer to conduct a stop based on reasonable suspicion of drug possession.The defendant, identified as the male driver after a seat change, was found to be a certified habitual offender and admitted to having purchased fentanyl, which was located on the female passenger. He was charged with operating after certification as a habitual offender. He moved to suppress evidence from the stop, arguing lack of reasonable suspicion. The Rockingham County Superior Court concluded the officer’s observations and prior tips did not establish reasonable suspicion and granted the motion to suppress.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed the case de novo. It held that, viewing the totality of the circumstances—including prior reliable tips, the known drug-related activity at both apartment complexes, and the officer’s observations—the officer had reasonable suspicion to justify the investigatory stop. The court reversed the suppression order and remanded the case for further proceedings. View "State v. Hefferon" on Justia Law

by
The defendant was involved in a domestic violence incident with a former romantic partner with whom he continued to live as a roommate. On September 18, 2022, after drinking heavily, the defendant assaulted the victim by choking, hitting, and threatening her. The victim, fearing further violence, submitted to sexual acts. After the defendant fell asleep, the victim left, sought medical attention, and reported the incident to police. The defendant was arrested and, while detained pending trial, communicated with the victim numerous times, encouraging her to lie and withhold information from authorities, and discouraging her from testifying.The Hillsborough-northern judicial district Superior Court conducted a jury trial. The jury acquitted the defendant of some charges but convicted him of aggravated felonious sexual assault-domestic violence, stalking-domestic violence, indirect criminal contempt, witness tampering, criminal restraint, second degree assault-domestic violence, and simple assault-domestic violence. The defendant appealed these convictions.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed the case. It affirmed the aggravated felonious sexual assault convictions, holding that there was sufficient evidence to find the victim was confined and did not freely consent to the sexual acts due to fear provoked by prior assaults. The court reversed the stalking and indirect criminal contempt convictions, concluding that the bail statute in effect at the time did not authorize no-contact orders for detained defendants, rendering the evidence insufficient for those charges. The court found no double jeopardy violation regarding multiple witness tampering convictions, determining that each attempt to influence the victim constituted a separate offense. Other double jeopardy claims were rejected due to insufficient demonstration of plain error. The Supreme Court of New Hampshire affirmed the remaining convictions and reversed the stalking and contempt convictions. View "State v. Sales" on Justia Law

by
A property in Hollis was owned by a trust with Wisarat Manutsom as trustee. The trustee, often traveling abroad, provided various mailing addresses—including in California, Manchester (New Hampshire), and later Maine—as well as an email address, to the town for tax-related correspondence. Mark Copp was authorized to act for the trust and provided his Manchester address. Over several years, the town sent multiple certified mail notices regarding unpaid property taxes and impending tax liens and deeds to these addresses; some were signed for and received, but several were returned as undeliverable. The town also communicated about the delinquent taxes by email. In 2019, after more undelivered certified mailings and no payment for 2016 taxes, the town executed a tax deed transferring ownership to itself, then sent post-deed notices by regular mail and, years later, by certified mail and email.The plaintiff sued in the Superior Court, alleging the town’s notice regarding the 2016 and 2018 tax liens and the 2016 tax deed was constitutionally deficient under the Fourteenth Amendment. The Superior Court granted summary judgment to the town, finding the notice sufficient. The plaintiff's motion for reconsideration was denied, and she appealed.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed the case de novo. It held that the town’s failure to take additional reasonable steps—such as emailing notice—after certified notices of the impending 2016 tax deed were returned undelivered, and before executing the deed, violated the plaintiff’s due process rights. The court also found the town’s notice of the 2016 tax lien insufficient because it relied on an address that had repeatedly failed. However, notice of the 2018 tax lien, sent to both Manchester and Maine addresses, was deemed sufficient. The court affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded for further proceedings. View "Manutsom v. Town of Hollis" on Justia Law

by
The defendant was convicted of voting in more than one state during the 2016 general election. He maintained residences in both New Hampshire and Massachusetts and was alleged to have voted in Holderness, New Hampshire by absentee ballot and in Belmont, Massachusetts in person. The State introduced evidence of his voting history in both states from 1996 to 2018 and sought to exclude statements by an acquaintance, William Botelho, who had previously admitted to voting in the defendant's name in Massachusetts.The Grafton County Superior Court allowed the State to admit the defendant’s prior voting records under New Hampshire Rule of Evidence 404(b) and excluded Botelho’s statements as inadmissible propensity evidence, also denying the defendant’s request for a Richards hearing regarding Botelho’s potential testimony. After a jury found the defendant guilty, the Superior Court denied his post-trial motions for dismissal based on territorial jurisdiction, judgment notwithstanding the verdict, and to set aside the verdict.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire found that the Superior Court erred in admitting the defendant’s prior voting history because the danger of unfair prejudice substantially outweighed its probative value, especially since the prior alleged acts were nearly identical to the charged crime. The court also held that evidence of Botelho’s confession to voting in the defendant’s name in the 2016 election was not evidence of other bad acts under Rule 404(b) and should not have been categorically excluded. The Supreme Court further ruled that, if Botelho asserts his Fifth Amendment rights on remand, the trial court must hold a Richards hearing.The Supreme Court affirmed the lower court’s denial of the defendant’s motions regarding territorial jurisdiction, sufficiency, and weight of the evidence, but reversed the conviction due to the evidentiary errors and remanded for further proceedings. View "State v. Rosen" on Justia Law

by
The defendant, a patient at a community mental health center, was informed by his career counselor that he had been dismissed from classes at UNH Manchester and would be removed by security if he returned to campus. Distressed by this news, he insisted he would still attend his evening class. In communications with his counselor and later his therapist, he reiterated his plan to attend, culminating in a statement asking if “doing a mass shooting” would be required for him to get what he wanted. When told his statement would be reported, he claimed it was a figure of speech. The counselor reported his comments to the treatment team and local police, in accordance with center policy. Law enforcement notified UNH Manchester, which took security precautions, and later apprehended the defendant. He was indicted for criminal threatening based on his statements.Prior to trial in the Superior Court, the defendant sought to exclude the testimony of his counselor and therapist regarding his statements, asserting the therapist-patient privilege, and also moved to dismiss for insufficiency of the evidence. The Superior Court denied both motions, finding an “essential need” for the privileged communications and concluding that a reasonable jury could find the defendant guilty. The jury convicted the defendant of criminal threatening.On appeal, the Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed whether the trial court properly allowed admission of the privileged communications and whether the evidence was sufficient for conviction. The court held that the State demonstrated an “essential need” to pierce the therapist-patient privilege due to the centrality of the communications to the charged offense and the compelling public safety interest in investigating threats of mass violence. The court also found the evidence sufficient for a rational jury to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant acted in reckless disregard for causing fear, terror, or public inconvenience. The conviction was affirmed. View "State v. Stewart" on Justia Law

by
The case concerns allegations of sexual abuse committed by the defendant against a complainant when she was between the ages of four and ten during visits to the defendant’s home. The complainant testified that the defendant engaged in multiple acts of sexual assault over several years, including threats to her and her family to ensure her silence. After the complainant disclosed the abuse to her mother, law enforcement became involved, which led to the defendant’s indictment on multiple charges, including pattern aggravated felonious sexual assault, felonious sexual assault, and criminal threatening.In Superior Court, the defendant moved for in camera review of the complainant’s counseling records, which the court partially granted. The State successfully moved to allow the complainant to testify by two-way live video feed from outside the defendant’s presence, arguing that testifying in front of the defendant would cause her trauma and render her unavailable. During the trial, the complainant testified remotely. After the State rested, several charges were dismissed or nol prossed by agreement, and the jury ultimately convicted the defendant on the remaining counts.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed the case. It held that allowing the complainant to testify remotely, outside the defendant’s presence, violated his confrontation right under Part I, Article 15 of the New Hampshire Constitution as interpreted in State v. Warren. The court found that this right requires a face-to-face, in-person meeting between the accused and the witness. The court also held that the evidence was insufficient to support the conviction for one pattern aggravated felonious sexual assault charge involving sexual intercourse, as the complainant’s testimony did not establish that the acts occurred over the required statutory period. The court reversed the conviction on that charge and remanded the remaining convictions for further proceedings, vacating the trial court’s discovery order in part for additional review in light of a recent precedent. View "State v. Brousseau" on Justia Law

by
The defendant owned a house on Farm Island, New Hampshire, near a summer camp with which he had a history of disputes. After hearing a group outside his house at night, he yelled at them and, when unable to reach the police, left a voicemail for the camp, using profane language and stating, “you better get them the f**k out of here or I will shoot them.” He also accused the group of damaging his property. The State charged him with harassment, alleging that his communication constituted a threat to the life or safety of another, made with the purpose to annoy or alarm.The Superior Court of Carroll County held a jury trial. During trial, the State introduced the voicemail, evidence of the contentious relationship between the defendant and the camp, and testimony from camp staff and police. Over the defendant’s objections, the court admitted testimony from a camp director about security measures the camp undertook in response to the message, including ceasing use of part of the island and enhancing security. The defendant moved to dismiss for insufficient evidence of the required mental state; the court denied the motion. The jury convicted the defendant, and he appealed.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed the case. It held that there was sufficient evidence for a rational trier of fact to find the defendant acted with the purpose to annoy or alarm and that the communication constituted a true threat as defined by federal law. However, the court found that admitting testimony about the camp’s security response was error under New Hampshire Rule of Evidence 403, as its limited probative value was substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. This error was not harmless. The Supreme Court of New Hampshire therefore reversed the conviction and remanded for a new trial. View "State v. Owen" on Justia Law

by
Twenty-three landowners brought suit against Gold Bess Shooting Club, LLC and Caulder Construction, LLC, alleging nuisance due to noise, environmental, and safety concerns from a shooting range established on Caulder’s property in Woodstock, New Hampshire. Gold Bess registered as an LLC and leased land from Caulder, constructing the range and opening it to the public in October 2020. Prior to its opening, the New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services notified the defendants of alleged violations of state wetlands and terrain alteration statutes. The plaintiffs amended their complaint to add noise-related nuisance claims after Woodstock enacted a noise ordinance in April 2021.The Grafton County Superior Court granted summary judgment to the defendants on the plaintiffs’ noise-related nuisance claims, finding the shooting range immune under RSA 159-B:1 and RSA 159-B:2, which provide protection from civil liability related to noise for shooting ranges compliant with noise ordinances in effect when the range was established, constructed, or began operations. The court denied plaintiffs’ motion for partial summary judgment and rejected their argument that alleged environmental law violations precluded immunity under RSA chapter 159-B. The court also granted summary judgment for the defendants on constitutional equal protection claims, and subsequently allowed the plaintiffs to voluntarily discontinue their remaining claims.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed the statutory interpretation of RSA 159-B:1 and RSA 159-B:2 de novo. It held that these statutes require compliance only with noise ordinances, not with other laws such as wetlands or terrain alteration statutes. The court further determined that the shooting range “began operations” prior to the enactment of Woodstock’s noise ordinance, thereby qualifying for immunity from noise-related legal claims under the statutes. The Supreme Court affirmed the Superior Court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of the defendants. View "Martell v. Gold Bess Shooting Club, LLC" on Justia Law

by
The plaintiff alleged that he was sexually abused by a priest while attending a summer camp in the mid-1970s, which was managed by the defendants. At the time of the alleged abuse, New Hampshire law required minors to bring personal actions within two years after reaching the age of majority. The plaintiff, born in 1966, did not file his complaint before the limitations period expired in 1986. Decades later, the legislature amended the relevant statute, RSA 508:4-g, first to extend and then, in 2020, to remove the statute of limitations for personal actions based on sexual assault. The plaintiff filed his complaint in 2023, seeking to take advantage of the amended law.The Superior Court (Leonard, J.) dismissed the complaint, holding that the claim was time-barred because the statute of limitations had expired in 1986. The court further ruled that applying the 2020 amendment to revive the plaintiff’s claim would violate Part I, Article 23 of the New Hampshire Constitution, which prohibits retrospective laws. The plaintiff’s motion to reconsider was denied, and he appealed.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire reviewed the case de novo. It assumed, without deciding, that the legislature intended the 2020 amendment to apply retroactively, but held that doing so would be unconstitutional. The court reaffirmed longstanding precedent that a defendant acquires a vested right to a statute of limitations defense once the limitations period has expired, and that this right cannot be abrogated by subsequent legislation. The court declined to overrule this precedent or to adopt a balancing test weighing the plaintiff’s right to recover against the defendants’ vested right. The Supreme Court of New Hampshire affirmed the dismissal, holding that the constitutional prohibition against retrospective laws precludes application of the amended statute to revive the plaintiff’s time-barred claim. View "Ball v. Roman Catholic Bishop of Manchester" on Justia Law

by
The case involves a challenge to the constitutionality of the State of New Hampshire's funding for public education. The plaintiffs, which include several school districts and individuals, argue that the amount of base adequacy aid provided under RSA 198:40-a, II(a) is insufficient to cover the cost of providing a constitutionally adequate education as defined by RSA 193-E:2-a. They seek a declaratory judgment and injunctive relief to increase the funding.The Superior Court (Ruoff, J.) ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, declaring RSA 198:40-a, II(a) unconstitutional on its face. The court found that the current funding level of $4,100 per pupil was significantly below the amount necessary to provide an adequate education. The court determined a conservative minimum threshold of $7,356.01 per pupil, which it found to be the minimum amount that base adequacy aid must exceed. The court also directed the State to immediately increase base adequacy aid payments to this threshold amount pending further legislative action.The State appealed to the Supreme Court of New Hampshire, arguing that the trial court erred in its findings and that the immediate payment directive violated the separation of powers doctrine. The State contended that the trial court should have considered the total funding provided under RSA 198:40-a, including differentiated aid, rather than focusing solely on base adequacy aid.The Supreme Court of New Hampshire affirmed the trial court's rulings on the admissibility of expert testimony, the declaration that RSA 198:40-a, II(a) is facially unconstitutional, and the determination of a conservative minimum threshold for base adequacy aid. However, the court reversed the trial court's immediate payment directive, finding that it failed to properly weigh separation of powers concerns and the history of school funding litigation. The court emphasized the need for the legislative and executive branches to act expeditiously to remedy the constitutional deficiency in funding public education. View "Contoocook Valley Sch. Dist. v. State" on Justia Law